How to Respond to an IRS Request for Information (RFI)

An IRS request for information (RFI) is a letter asking your nonprofit for more detail before the IRS decides your tax-exempt application. The most important facts are these: the letter sets a deadline, you answer every numbered item in order, you label every page with your name and EIN, and you keep proof of what you sent. This guide walks through each step so you can reply completely and on time.

This article is general information only. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Chisholm Law Firm.

Chisholm Law Firm
Respond to the IRS with confidence
Chisholm Law Firm provides legal services for nonprofits seeking tax-exempt status and navigating compliance challenges.

Explore nonprofit legal services

TL;DR

  • An RFI means the reviewer needs more information to finish your application. It is common, and it is not a denial.
  • The IRS generally allows 28 calendar days from the mailing date of the letter. Extensions are possible but usually short, and you must ask before the due date.
  • Answer each numbered item in order. Put your name and EIN on every page, and cite the Part and Line number of the form each answer relates to.
  • A late or incomplete response can lead to the case closing without a refund of the user fee, or to a proposed adverse determination.
  • Send the package in a way you can track, and keep a full copy permanently.

Table of Contents

What an IRS request for information is

When you apply for recognition of exemption, a reviewer reads your application and your attachments. If the reviewer decides more information is needed to complete the review, the IRS issues a letter requesting that information by a specified date. That letter is the RFI.

The practice is not limited to one form. The IRS uses information requests for Form 1023, Form 1023-EZ in pre-determination reviews, Form 1024, Form 1028 and letter applications. So a social welfare organization seeking 501©(4) recognition or a trade association applying under 501©(6) can receive one just as a new charity can.

Common reasons include:

  • Your narrative of activities was too thin to show how you will operate.
  • Your bylaws or articles are missing a required provision, or the documents conflict with each other.
  • The projected budget does not match the programs you described.
  • Compensation, related-party arrangements or contracts need explanation.
  • A schedule or attachment was left out.

The reviewer’s goal is to understand your organization well enough to apply the law. A clear answer usually moves the file forward. Our own article on why 501©(3) applications get rejected covers the gaps that most often trigger these letters, and fixing them in your first filing can prevent an RFI altogether.

Read the letter before you do anything else

Each IRS notice deals with a specific issue and includes specific instructions on what to do. Your letter, not this article, controls. Before you begin drafting, mark up your copy:

  1. The mailing date and the response due date. Put both on the board calendar.
  2. The numbered requests. Highlight each one. Note whether it asks for a document, an explanation or both.
  3. The return address or fax number. Use exactly what the letter gives you.
  4. The contact person and phone number. The letter names the IRS employee handling your case.

The IRS also tells its reviewers to phone the organization’s authorized contact on the day the request is mailed. According to IRS procedures, the call is meant to explain the requirements and stress the importance of meeting the deadline. That means the contact person listed on your application should be someone who checks voicemail and email, and who knows to tell the rest of the board right away.

The deadline and how to ask for more time

The IRS generally sets the due date at 28 calendar days from the mailing date of the additional information request letter. Count from the date on the letter, not from the day it reached your mailbox. Mail can be slow, so the real working window is often shorter than it looks.

If you cannot finish, ask before the due date passes. The same IRS procedures say extensions are typically granted for 14 days or less, depending on facts and circumstances, with longer periods available for specific needs such as amending state filings. Practical points:

  • Call the contact named in the letter and follow up in writing if the letter allows it.
  • Say exactly what remains and why it needs more time. “We are waiting on the state to file our amended articles” is a reason. “We are busy” is not.
  • Do not treat a request as granted until the IRS confirms it. Note the date, time and name of the person you spoke with.

If the reason for the delay is a legal question, such as how to describe a program or whether to amend your governing documents, talk to a nonprofit attorney before the clock runs out, not after.

Build the response package

A complete reply is organized, answers what was asked and nothing more, and is easy for a reviewer to check against the letter.

Identify every page

The IRS instructs that supplemental responses must include the organization’s name and EIN on every page, and must explicitly identify the Part and Line number to which the information relates. Pages get separated in processing. A page without your EIN may as well not exist.

Answer in the order of the letter

We recommend a simple structure:

  1. Cover letter. One page. Your legal name, EIN, the date of the IRS letter, the IRS contact’s name and a list of what is enclosed.
  2. Narrative answers. Repeat each numbered request in bold, then answer directly underneath it. Keep the same numbering the IRS used.
  3. Exhibits. Label each attachment (Exhibit A, Exhibit B) and reference it in the narrative. Dividers or tabs make a paper package easier to navigate.
  4. Index. A one-page table of contents listing each request, the page where the answer begins and the exhibits that support it.

Resist the urge to add background the reviewer did not ask for. Extra material can raise new questions, and a long package makes the real answers harder to find. If an answer is “none,” say so in a sentence.

Send copies, not originals

Unless the letter specifically asks for an original, send photocopies or clean scans of your records and keep the originals in your corporate record book.

What to include for common requests

The right evidence depends on the question. These are the categories we see most often.

Governing documents

If you have adopted bylaws, the IRS says you must submit a copy if requested during the application review. Send the version actually adopted by your board, signed or certified as the IRS expects, and make sure it matches your articles of incorporation. If the reviewer asks about a missing purpose or dissolution clause, you may need to amend your articles with your state first and then send the filed-stamped amendment. That is the situation where an extension request is most likely to be reasonable.

Because bylaws are often a pain point, our Founders Protection™ Bylaws offering addresses governance drafting for new nonprofits.

Activities and program descriptions

To understand what your organization really does, the IRS often asks for copies of advertising, publications, materials expressing views on legislation, and contracts, leases or agreements. Give the reviewer a plain description of who you serve, what you do, who does it, where it happens, how it is paid for and how much time each activity takes.

If your programs include special events or donor-facing activities, describe them accurately and in concrete terms. For context on how different event formats work, you can look at a guide to rare disease fundraising event types and then explain, in your own words, which format you actually use, how often, and who benefits. Do not copy generic language into your response. The reviewer wants facts about your organization.

Activities and program descriptions — overview diagram

Financial information

When the reviewer questions your projected revenue or expenses, strong support is concrete: a program budget with line items, signed grant agreements or award letters, pledge documentation and bank statements if you already have activity. Show how each assumption ties to a real source. If your numbers changed since you filed, say so, explain why and provide the updated figures instead of leaving the reviewer to find the mismatch.

If the letter asks about officers, directors or relatives, give names, roles, compensation methods and how the board approves them. Attach any written agreements. This is an area where a wrong answer can create an operational problem, so have counsel read it first.

How to send it and prove it arrived

The letter tells you where and how to respond. Follow it. The research we reviewed also supports a few habits that protect you:

  • Use a trackable method. USPS certified mail with a return receipt shows when the package was delivered. Courier tracking works as well. Staple the receipt to your file copy.
  • Do not email tax data unless the IRS specifically tells you that email is acceptable for your case.
  • Keep a complete copy of everything you send, in the same order, including the cover letter and the index.
  • Log the follow-up. Note the date you mailed, the delivery confirmation date and any call or message from the IRS.

On retention, IRS Publication 4221-PC explains that a public charity should keep records that support its compliance and filings. Records supporting an income or deduction item are generally kept until the limitations period runs, usually three years after the return is due or filed, whichever is later. Some records, including the exemption application, the determination letter and organizing documents, should be kept permanently. Your RFI response belongs with the exemption application in that permanent file. Our guide to keeping legal records that meet IRS standards shows how to organize it.

What happens if you are late, incomplete or silent

The consequences are real, which is why the deadline matters.

Both outcomes cost time and money. Refiling means a new application and a new fee. Verify the current filing fee on the IRS form instructions before you budget, because government fees change. A proposed adverse determination gives you limited options, so it is far better to answer fully the first time.

Some common ways responses fall short:

MistakeWhy it hurtsFix
Skipping a numbered itemThe reviewer treats it as unansweredAnswer every item, even with “not applicable” and a reason
Missing EIN or line referencePages get detached or misreadPut name, EIN and Part and Line on every page
Vague narrativeThe same question comes back, or a denial followsUse specifics: who, what, where, when, how paid
Documents that conflictThe reviewer cannot tell which version governsAlign articles, bylaws and the narrative before sending
No proof of deliveryYou cannot show you met the deadlineUse certified mail or tracked courier and keep the receipt

Our perspective: treat the RFI as a second chance to tell your story

Most founders read an RFI as a warning. We read it as an invitation. The reviewer has already spent time with your file, and a specific question tells you exactly what stood between your application and approval.

In our work with nonprofit founders, the RFIs that cause the most trouble are not the hard ones. They are the ones that sit on a desk for three weeks because nobody on the board knew who was responsible. Our advice is to assign one person, calendar the due date the day the letter arrives, and build the response as a short, tidy package that a stranger could follow without calling you.

Our perspective: treat the RFI as a second chance to tell your story — overview diagram

We also encourage founders to look at the whole application, not just the one question. If the reviewer asked about your budget, check whether your narrative and bylaws tell the same story. A response that fixes the problem and quietly creates a new inconsistency invites a second letter. Our article on avoiding application pitfalls with a nonprofit lawyer explains how a second set of eyes catches these issues, and if you are wondering whether you can speed things up, see how to expedite your 501©(3) application.

Finally, remember that approval is the beginning of your compliance obligations. Once the determination letter arrives, the next questions are about annual reporting requirements and records, and the habits you build answering an RFI carry straight into them.

— Audrey K. Chisholm

Getting help with your response

If your organization has an open RFI and you want help preparing exemption-related documents, such as organizing documents, bylaws or the application materials themselves, our team works with nonprofit founders in all 50 states. See our nonprofit formation and tax-exemption services or contact us for a free consultation. Our services are limited to the scope we agree on in writing, and nothing here creates an attorney-client relationship until an engagement is in place.

A short checklist before you mail

  1. The due date is on the calendar and the package will be mailed with room to spare.
  2. Every numbered request has an answer, in the same order.
  3. Each page shows the organization’s name and EIN, and each answer cites its Part and Line number.
  4. Exhibits are labeled and referenced in the narrative.
  5. Governing documents match each other and match what you told the IRS.
  6. You are sending copies, not originals.
  7. A board officer has read the final package.
  8. You are using a tracked delivery method, and you have a complete copy for the permanent file.

FAQ

How long do we have to respond to an IRS RFI?

The IRS generally sets the due date at 28 calendar days from the mailing date on the letter. Your letter states the exact date, and that date controls. If you need more time, ask before it passes.

Can we get an extension?

Yes, the IRS allows requests made before the due date. Extensions are typically 14 days or less, based on the facts, though longer periods can be available for needs like state filing amendments. Confirm any extension with the IRS contact named in your letter.

Can we email our response?

Only if the IRS has told you to. Follow the delivery instructions in your letter, and avoid sending tax data through unsecured email otherwise. Use certified mail with a return receipt or a tracked courier so you can prove delivery.

What if we cannot provide something the IRS asked for?

Say so in the numbered answer and explain why. If the item does not exist yet, describe your plan and timeline. Do not leave it blank. If the gap affects whether you qualify for exemption, speak with a nonprofit attorney before you respond.

Does an RFI mean our application will be denied?

No. It means the reviewer needs more information to finish the review. A complete, organized response gives the IRS what it needs to decide. The risks come from missing the deadline or sending an incomplete answer.

Sources