3 Charity Auction Compliance Rules for U.S. Nonprofits: $75 Disclosures
Charity auctions carry three non-negotiable obligations under federal and state law: organizers must disclose quid pro quo payments over $75 in writing, donors may only deduct the amount they pay above an item’s fair market value, and every nonprofit must confirm state solicitation, sales-tax, and gaming rules before the gavel falls. Missing any one of these can cost donors their deduction and expose the organization to penalties.
TL;DR:
- Donors must receive written disclosures for payments over $75 in charity auctions, or organizations risk penalties and lost deductions.
- The deductible amount is limited to payments exceeding the fair market value of auctioned items, with detailed records required for high-value donations.
- State registration and licensing, especially for out-of-state bidders and raffles, vary widely and must be confirmed before the event.
- Sales tax collection is often mandatory for auction items unless explicitly exempt, and organizers should verify requirements in their state beforehand.
- Large or frequent auctions should consult professionals to manage unrelated business income tax risks and ensure comprehensive compliance.
Table of Contents
- Quick checklist for auction compliance
- IRS rules on disclosures, deductions, and penalties
- State solicitation registration and gaming law differences
- Sales tax and unrelated business income considerations
- Step-by-step compliance timeline for your auction
- Common pitfalls that trigger audits or complaints
- When to bring in nonprofit legal counsel
- Why compliance protects your fundraising, not just your paperwork
- How our firm supports nonprofit auction compliance
- FAQ
- Sources
Quick checklist for auction compliance
Before you open the floor to bidders, a few tasks protect your organization and your donors at the same time.
- Publish fair market value estimates and auction terms before bidding opens.
- Provide written quid pro quo disclosures for any payment over $75.
- Confirm your state charitable solicitation registration is current in every state where you solicit.
- Verify sales-tax registration and collection requirements for auctioned goods.
- Collect buyer contact information so you can issue proper acknowledgement letters.
The disclosure threshold is firm: under IRS rules on charity auctions, a written statement is required whenever a donor’s payment exceeds $75, and skipping it can trigger a penalty per contribution. Treat this threshold as a planning deadline, not an afterthought.
IRS rules on disclosures, deductions, and penalties
A quid pro quo contribution happens whenever a donor pays more than the fair market value of what they receive in return, which describes nearly every auction purchase. Once that payment exceeds $75, IRS guidance on charity auctions requires a written disclosure statement that does two things: it explains that the deductible portion of the payment is limited to the amount exceeding the item’s fair market value, and it gives the donor a good-faith estimate of that value.
The math itself is simple once FMV is set. Say a donor pays $300 for a weekend getaway package with a documented fair market value of $200. The deductible portion is $100, the difference between what was paid and what was received. The donor carries the burden of proving that deduction if the IRS asks, which is exactly why your disclosure statement matters.

A separate wrinkle applies to donated property itself. When a donor contributes an item that your organization later sells, rather than uses in its programs, the IRS explains that the donor’s deduction is generally limited to their tax basis in the item, not its full fair market value, because the sale counts as an unrelated use. High-value items may also trigger Form 8283 and formal appraisal requirements for the donor.
Penalties for skipping disclosure are specific:
- A penalty of ten dollars per contribution, with a maximum penalty per fundraising event, applies when a required quid pro quo disclosure is missing, as stated in IRS charity auction guidance.
- Organizations can avoid the penalty by showing reasonable cause for the omission, according to IRS guidance on substantiating contributions.
- Disclosure is required once payment exceeds $75, even if the deductible portion itself works out to less than $75.
State solicitation registration and gaming law differences
Charitable solicitation laws exist separately from federal tax rules, and they vary widely by state. Most states require a nonprofit to register before soliciting contributions from their residents, with exemptions that depend on organization type, revenue level, or how the solicitation is conducted. If your auction invites out-of-state donors to bid online or by proxy, you may need to register in each of those states too, not just your home state.
Auctions and raffles are not the same thing legally, and confusing them is a common misstep. An auction is a sale: the highest bidder pays for a specific item at an agreed price. A raffle is a lottery: participants buy a chance at a prize, which means gaming laws, not sales law, govern it. Running a raffle alongside your auction, even informally with a jar of tickets, can trigger separate licensing and reporting obligations that your auction permit does not cover.
Before your event, check three things:
- Your state’s charitable solicitation registration portal, to confirm your filing is current.
- Whether you need separate professional fundraiser or solicitor registration if you hired outside help.
- Local or state licensing requirements for any raffle, bingo-style game, or prize drawing included alongside the auction.
Pro Tip: Keep your auction and any raffle elements legally and operationally separate, down to separate ticket sales and separate signage, so a gaming-law question about one never puts your auction registration at risk.
Sales tax and unrelated business income considerations
Auctioned items are tangible property changing hands for payment, which means state sales tax rules often apply the same way they would to a retail sale. Many states expect nonprofits to register and collect sales tax on auctioned goods unless a specific nonprofit or fundraising exemption applies, and that exemption is never automatic. Check your state revenue department’s rules before the event, not after you have already sold the items.
A separate question is whether auction proceeds could count as unrelated business taxable income. The core factors are regularity and commerciality: an occasional, volunteer-run fundraising auction looks very different to the IRS than a recurring, commercially run sales operation. A once-a-year benefit auction typically falls outside UBIT exposure, but an organization running frequent, high-volume sales events should get that risk reviewed.
A few habits keep your reporting clean:
- Record gross auction sales separately from other event revenue.
- Report fundraising event income on Schedule G and Form 990 using the breakdown described in the IRS Audit Technique Guide for Fundraising Activities.
- Loop in a tax advisor whenever your auction program grows large enough that UBIT becomes a realistic question.
Step-by-step compliance timeline for your auction
Breaking compliance into a timeline keeps nothing from slipping through during a busy event season.
- Pre-event: Compile fair market value estimates for every donated item, confirm your state solicitation registration is active, draft your written disclosure language, and determine whether sales-tax registration applies.
- Night-of: Publish FMV figures and disclosure language on lot signage and in the printed program, capture buyer contact details at checkout, and issue receipts that clearly separate the FMV portion from the deductible gift portion.
- Post-event: Send acknowledgement letters, especially for any single contribution of $250 or more, retain your valuation records, complete Form 8283 where appraisal thresholds apply, and reconcile everything against your Schedule G and Form 990 filings.
| Phase | Core task | Governing rule |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-event | Set FMV, confirm registration | State solicitation statutes |
| Night-of | Disclose, collect buyer data | $75 quid pro quo threshold (IRS) |
| Post-event | Acknowledge, reconcile filings | Schedule G / Form 990 reporting (IRS ATG) |
Common pitfalls that trigger audits or complaints
Most auction compliance failures trace back to a handful of repeated mistakes.
- Skipping written disclosure when a bidder’s payment exceeds $75, even when the organizer assumes the item’s value is obvious.
- Publishing FMV figures with no donor documentation or appraisal to back them up.
- Treating a raffle as if it were just another auction lot, without the separate gaming license it actually requires.
- Forgetting to register for sales tax, or registering in your home state while ignoring obligations in every other state where you solicited bidders.
Pro Tip: Build your FMV documentation and your disclosure language at the same time you confirm each donated item, not the week before the event, when there is no time left to track down a missing appraisal.
When to bring in nonprofit legal counsel
Our team focuses specifically on nonprofit compliance, which means auction questions come up frequently in nonprofit contexts. A few situations call for counsel rather than a checklist:
- You are soliciting bidders across multiple states and need to confirm registration in each one.
- A donated item is valuable enough to require a qualified appraisal or Form 8283 filing.
- Your auction program has grown large or frequent enough that unrelated business income tax exposure is a real possibility, not a theoretical one.
Our charitable solicitation registration guide and donation receipt requirements checklist walk through the documentation side in more detail.
Why compliance protects your fundraising, not just your paperwork
Getting disclosure and valuation right is not red tape standing between you and the money. It is what keeps a donor’s trust intact after the event ends, which is what brings them back next year. Skip the appraisal on a high-value experiential item, or hand out a vague receipt, and you risk a donor’s deduction and your organization’s credibility in the same motion.
— Audrey K. Chisholm
How our firm supports nonprofit auction compliance
Our practice addresses questions like those raised in this article, so organizers do not have to piece together federal tax rules and state solicitation law on their own. Our team reviews auction terms, drafts donation-receipt language that meets IRS disclosure standards, confirms charitable solicitation registration across every state where you fundraise, and advises on sales-tax and unrelated business income questions before they become filing problems.

We offer support for organizers preparing for an auction season, including charitable solicitation registration review and filing support, donation-receipt and quid pro quo disclosure templates aligned with IRS standards, auction terms and conditions review, and sales-tax and unrelated business income counseling for growing auction programs.
If your auction program is expanding or crossing state lines, visit our fundraising compliance services page to schedule a consultation before your next event goes to print.
This article is general information, not a substitute for advice from a qualified financial advisor. Consult a qualified financial professional about your own circumstances before acting on anything here.

FAQ
What is the 30/70 rule for charities?
There is no IRS rule governing charity auctions or nonprofit operations matching this term. If you encountered this term describing a specific fundraising platform’s fee split or a state’s own gaming regulation, confirm it directly with that source, since it is not a federal tax standard.
What is the 80/20 rule for charities?
There is no official IRS rule matching this description for charities. Some fundraising conversations use ratios informally to describe donor concentration or expense ratios, but these are not federal auction or tax-exemption requirements, so check any specific claim against its original source.
Can you write off a charity auction item?
You can deduct only the portion of your payment that exceeds the item’s fair market value, according to IRS guidance on charity auctions. If you donate an item that the charity later sells rather than uses, your deduction is generally limited to your tax basis in that item.
What are the new rules for charitable giving in 2026?
The core IRS rules covered here, the $75 quid pro quo disclosure threshold, the FMV-based deduction formula, and the $10-per-contribution penalty up to $5,000 per event, remain the governing standards according to IRS charity auction guidance. Always confirm state solicitation and sales-tax requirements separately, since those can change by state and by filing year.